Having a same-age, equally gifted cohort is so important. I was in an excellent gifted program through 8th grade. I was the best student in my class, but only had a couple of friends. For high school, I went off to a public boarding school for math + science nerds. I was no longer the top student -- far from it -- but I finally had a normal social life. My roommates and I stayed up all night playing video games and listening to illegally downloaded mp3s. I dated a boy who I met on the math team.
It's sad how California has turned away from gifted education. My husband grew up in California and didn't have any friends until he started in a GATE program in 4th grade. He's still good friends with his GATE classmates. Today, GATE doesn't really exist. Even if a district has a process for identifying gifted kids, they aren't pulled out into a separate class or program. They don't get to meet their peers until high school or maybe even college.
I understand that the public schools need to focus on the kids at the other end of the spectrum, but it gives me little motivation to enroll my own son in a public school.
I went to Yale when I was 16, which was a regrettable decision, but I'll save the story for another comment.
That's powerful stuff. I also had a rough time in school and with my mental health. I also took comfort in Zen Speaks, Laozi Speaks, Confucius Speaks, growing up. The Chinese language ones came out in 1987 and 1988, when I was 6 or 7 years old, my godparents gave them to me.
My first involuntary admit was at age 6 for an autistic meltdown (in the 1980s) and I was brought in by the police. My parents were pissed. I grew up in District 75 - segregated special ed, and considered too dangerous to be around normal kids.
Because of this, I was harangued by my parents for being in a punitive, segregated public school in the first place, compared to gifted kids who attended Bronx Science, and for my hospitalizations bankrupting them. So and so's kid goes to Brooklyn Tech, and you don't even have a chance to prove yourself due to a forced IEP.
What a forced IEP meant was, even if I passed the Brooklyn Tech exam, I was barred due to my court appointed, "needs".
For my weekends, I wanted Chinese school and academic cram school and violin, not autism therapies. I came from a perfect, hard working immigrant family, my mom worked 60 hours a week, with so many resources that my brother was gifted. But I knew we were more privileged than most other families.
I felt even smaller when I realized, that gifted kids parents were poorer than mine. That their families of five lived in studio apartments, while we had 1 bedroom. Meanwhile I got the cops called on me at school because I didn't know I was being aggressive in my tone of voice. They call it a lack of insight in psychology.
I felt ashamed of being special needs. But now that I read the experiences of gifted kids I realize I maybe didn't get the short end of the stick after all. Gifted school is a form of special ed, too.
I eventually got along, we played connect 4, Jenga, and Uno. My school mates escape was Hip Hop, Anime, and arcade games similar to D&D, such as Street Fighter. This wasn't permitted under afterschool rules, and a bunch of us got teacher and state enforced parental punishments *at home* because we watched Akira. Nevertheless, I internalized the feelings of inferiority. As we got older, antipsychotics made most people gain weight. I didn't see people doing well. It sucked. I wanted to do well and to escape the special ed scene.
Now in my 40s, I notice that nobody in my school got married or had kids. I'm glad that you were able to have a kid and escape the cycle. I am 44 years old and as a female growing up in special schools I don't want my kid to go through the demoralization and 2 hour short bus rides. But at the same time gifted school isn't the answer either.
School is supposed to teach you reading, writing and arithmetic and to connect you to the kids around you in your neighborhood. My brother went to a gifted high school in Brooklyn. This also gave him problems because he had less diverse life experiences. As you can see yourself, the high pressure in gifted schools can make you suicidal until you start reading the Bible. The solution, IMO is to just have zoned schools. I think we should be connecting to our neighbors. The one room school house? Yes please.
Well my point is, it sounds like gifted labeling is just as bad as special ed. Especially due to the high expectations. It really sucks to be separated from your peers at a young age. For me, it happened earlier, and for you, it happened later, but no matter. It's still rough.
Thanks for sharing, I’ve had my own struggles with depression and suicidal ideation in my youth but would have trouble sharing any of it. I’m glad you can get out there and be true to yourself now. I’ve always been curious about spiritual experiences. I have always been a complete atheist who has never experienced anything remotely like that despite experimenting with psychedelics to see if I could have those kinds of experiences. Hallucinations and bad trips are not what I consider spiritual experiences. Then again I’m someone who doesn’t even respond well to mdma.
Thanks! I’m trying to share more about spiritual experience but it’s definitely tricky because the range of experience is so widespread, and people are very sensitive about it. What sort of curiosity do you have?
(And sorry that this comment took so long! This post got a lot of comments right away, and I got overwhelmed, so now I am coming back to it, but it’s been a few months in the meantime.)
Oddly relatable. I had similar ennui and was also institutionalized and medicated against my will in my youth, for weeks. I'm determined to ensure my children do not have similar, negative experiences and have come to similar conclusions as your cohort theory.
Thank you for sharing - I’m so sorry to hear that you had a similar experience. Please keep in touch about how your thoughts evolve in terms of handling this for children ❤️
(Side note, sorry that this comment took so long! This post got a lot of comments right away, and I got overwhelmed, so now I am coming back to it, but it’s been a few months in the meantime.)
Pet ferrets? I ❤️ ferrets! They're so playful and really cute, and I loved to watch them run around and explore. It's a lot like having kittens, which makes sense because both ferrets and cats fill basically the same evolutionary niche, being obligate carnivores that hunt mice and other small rodents. Mine liked to lick my forehead...
I can relate to much though far from all of this, and I have Thoughts (tm). I went to college at sixteen also-- but a "regular" college, after having gone to a very college-like New England preppy boarding school at twelve, and having taken AP classes in middle school. Do you remember the old show "Head of the Class" with Janice the 11 year old in AP history? I still cringe at the similarities sometimes. And now I have a nerdy 13 year old son, on a much more outwardly conventional trajectory, but with his own quirks and strengths that I love and find deeply fulfilling to engage with.
So, some thoughts:
-- I don't know where you grew up, but I grew up in rural upstate NY in the eighties, and am delighted that the Bay Area in 2025 is a totally different, infinitely easier place to be a nerdy kid. You just don't need to work much to find similarly-intellectual community. Also, there is no need to skip grades to get full intellectual stimulation, which is great, because while skipping grades was the right solution for my time and place, the resultant age difference had some BIG downsides. You can imagine the social challenges of being a twelve-year-old ninth grade boy who is well under five feet tall and still has a soprano voice!
-- I also had excellent parents, who did a lot of aristocratic tutoring themselves despite their busyness, and hired tutors when they didn't have the time or subject matter expertise. Erik Hoel's posts about the effectiveness of aristocratic tutoring are spot on. But I hadn't appreciated, until my son got to reading age, how much easier it's gotten in our generation. Obviously a Kindle replaces many trips to the bookstore. Beast Academy and Art of Problem Solving are the best math teachers I know. But the most underrated trick I've found is strategic use of podcasts. Got chores, or hikes, or any other time-consuming activity your kid otherwise would get bored with? Put in the earbuds and put on a podcast. We started with Greeking Out and NPR's But Why and are now most of the way through the Mike Duncan oeuvre: History of Rome, Revolutions, and the fan-nonfic spinoffs like History of Byzantium.
-- Be careful with how you handle the Big Bang Theory. Sheldon Cooper is such an attractive character for "that type of kid" for obvious reasons... and such a terrible, terrible role model. I eventually had successful frank talks with my son about his flaws, but it took a few tries.
-- The other tricky problem I've found is how to handle conscientiousness-building. High intelligence so often comes with low, or relatively low, conscientiousness that ultimately limits agency. It certainly did for me: I could have been a much more successful research mathematician if I hadn't spent so much time playing Civ III in grad school, could have been a much more accomplished musician if I'd had any practice discipline at all before the age of 25, etc etc. I try and focus as much of my tutoring effort as I can around this, but it's always hard, emotionally and practically.
Thank you for commenting! I grew up in Hastings-on-Hudson, New York. It's a village in Westchester County, which is a bit north of New York City, on the Metro-North line. It is a really nice place, and overall I'm glad that I grew up there, but I haven't gone back in a long time.
I've had that thought about podcasts, but I have been remiss so far in exposing my son. I will redouble my efforts!
I walked through Hastings on Hudson the other day on a wooded trail passing between the Bronx, and the Croton reservoir. The crosswalk light was broken, and I got a bottle of water at Stop and Shop.
The route is called the Croton Aqueduct Trail and it traces the original path of water from the reservoir in Croton on Hudson, into the city. I start the route just south of Bronx Community College.
I remember the Aqueduct! It really is such a beautiful place. I made a drawing I liked of the Palisades when I was a teenager but I'm not sure if I still have a copy anywhere... maybe I'll see if my mother has one.
Nice. That’s awesome. I also enjoy walking around the Palisades, which are accessible by foot from the Washington Heights bridge. The Shore Trail is nice, but requires hard boots due to the sharp rocks. I consider you to be an honorary Native NYCer because Hastings is right over the border from the Bronx and basically the same as Yonkers.
I had gotten sidetracked last week, Lydia, but just finished this - thank you for sharing. I had not known about Simon's Rock but wish I had attended in another life. I was the only kindergartener in the GT program, skipped first grade, but my formal education was more or less a downhill disaster from there on out. I am still struggling to finish educating myself in both timeless and immediately useful ways while learning to make money, balance motherhood, etc. Hoping my kids can avoid some of this ... tumult.
I do go back and forth about the necessity of same age peers. Certainly there were times when I felt even 1-1.5 years of age gap clearly separated me from my classmates, post grade skip. But it was impossible to know how much of that was a factor of the lockstepedness of the grade system, or how I might have felt back with my age peers (possibly even worse). But many proposals for academic acceleration would result in more and bigger age gaps, though not enough to totally destabilize existing age-grade levels. Hard to say whether appropriate academics are or are not more important than staying with same age peers, and it's a false dichotomy anyways because enough bright kids exist to group them if we really want to.
Happily, this problem is completely avoided for us for now because GT School (like Alpha) uses moderately mixed age classrooms, 2-3 years, and advancement is dependent on meeting certain objectives so you can move up staggered throughout the year. This allows teachers to work on life skills that are appropriate for that age group but the apps will let those students work as far ahead at core academics as ends up being appropriate.
This all makes sense, Pamela! Thanks for sharing the info about GT School. I'm very curious about these up-and-coming tech-enabled education programs, all of which were unimaginable when I was a kid.
FWIW, our kid's Montessori school doesn't use any tech but similarly has mixed-age classrooms and lets kids move up at their own pace. I feel confident that he's being appropriately challenged, even if the program isn't targeted at gifted kids per se.
Good post, asking the right questions at times in your own way. I’ve come around to several of those questions too, partially because I graduated high school at 15 and was always acknowledged as gifted by parents who tried to lift me to full potential without understanding what that meant. But my story was different from yours socially and I realized quickly I didn’t want to be alone. Ironically, I’m now quite a solitary person despite looking normal and having had a career in - of all places -the military. But my course took me into an obsession with the development and shape of institutions and status, which is a topic some of those distasteful people are bringing up more openly. We need to talk about it, maybe not openly but with each other, having the experiences we have had.
What to do with intellect? What’s it for?
It’s very unpopular to say this, but I think you have to give the institutions a lot of leeway and the benefit of the doubt.
We don’t like this, because we’re a society filled with iconoclasm and fever dreams of personal freedom, all about authenticity and self expression.
But we’re also a bourgeois society, promoting equality and a comfortable, amiable conformity underneath the dressings of a liberated culture. The individualism is a reaction to that bourgeois conformity.
But that conformity is a reaction again, to societies that spent centuries and centuries built around aristocracy and a belief that some people were, both figuratively and measurably, better than others.
That’s so distasteful now, but we’re not over it. The child genius phenomenon was huge from the 70s to about 9/11, and no one asked why genius was importantly because it was so obvious. The geniuses would develop the technology, re-engineer the social norms and the culture. They had to be on top of the technocracy, as they were the only ones who understood it. It was taken for granted that status would be desirable but so would a desire to be normal, which is a paradox but one we were supposed to think of way out of, like concern for status was beneath real genius. It’s true and it’s not, and a lot of that goes back to our religious moral foundations.
There’s no easy answer, but more alarming for those with the intellect to spiral into these things, there’s no hard answer either. We run to communities that get us, but they aren’t better, just less lonely. We aren’t really better than those with a middling standard deviation, we can just do more, and we will never process all the conflicting variables that want to be accepted and trusted while also wanting to be the exception with greater relevance than the normal ones.
Life is messy. That’s all I’ve got, and I no longer believe there’s some light at the end of the tunnel where we can settle on anything other than just being whatever mask we make. I think I’m okay with that. It doesn’t hurt, it’s just the same discomfort every living thing goes through adapting to an environment that wasn’t built for us.
We aren’t owed an environment that’s built for us. That’s the fact for everyone, and those of us who respect our minds might rebel against it, but it’s an empty rebellion. We can build our spaces, but we will change within them. Maybe we want to find our true love in the entire universe, but we have to settle with being friends. It’s okay. We can take it.
Can you say more about how you think it would help to give institutions more leeway and benefit of the doubt on this subject? I have to say, I’ve just become more and more distrustful of them over time.
But we also need institutions. They are the context of our lives. Animals live in a natural environment, we live in a social environment, so while everyone wants to be a free thinker and unaffected, very few of us are in any significant way. The individual is a social construction.
So being interested in the institutions is necessary to understanding people. You can get political, changing what you don’t like, but it’s very difficult to pull off and there are deeper problems with the system and I don’t want to tell you what to believe. The most specific I want to get is just to remind you that you can, as it is, build your own new institutions right now. Being able to do that is the best aspect of where we are, and we aren’t doing it enough.
I’m not telling you to blindly follow. But I will tell you that rebellion for its own sake is keeping things from working well now.
When everyone dislikes the institutions, the people who try to get into them and gain position are going to be people with either little awareness or little interest in what their society thinks. In other words, dumb or trashy. Why would a good person who’s respected join an institution that’s widely seen as beneath respect?
That’s where we are. I know our culture worked better at one time, and I believe one of the reasons was because they interacted with authority in good faith, the critical aspect was moderated by some kind of ingrained respect.
I see. Totally agreed, and that’s basically where I landed on this question several years ago, too. I don’t see how we get out of this mess without building new institutions. OTOH, that’s exactly what Simon’s Rock tried to do, so one of the underlying themes in my essay here is the question of whether it could be considered a success or a failure
This is fascinating to me, because I had a sort-of similar experience that differs in all the most meaningful ways.
I don't know that I'm particularly intelligent (I've never taken an IQ test and it seems extraordinarily unlikely that I'd end up in the 150s), but I at least got good grades without any effort and won state math competitions, so I have to be a bit above average, I think. I was never bullied or ostracized for it though -- my family moved every one to two years growing up, so I think I was never part of the "background noise" enough to really be persistently targeted in any meaningful way. I didn't have any friendships that really mattered as a kid, but neither was I made fun of.
Around age 12 or 13, I lost my childhood faith (went from Catholic to atheist) and started thinking a lot about suicide. I never had a meaningful plan or anything and I never told anyone, so luckily this didn't cause me any particular problems (to this day, I've never talked to a therapist, and I seem to be getting along okay).
My own book that I got deeply obsessed with (circa age 14) to make sense of everything was The Stranger by Albert Camus, which I fell deeply in love with and reread endlessly, especially the ending right before the main character is executed:
"It was as if that great rush of anger had washed me clean, emptied me of hope, and, gazing up at the dark sky spangled with its signs and stars, for the first time, the first, I laid my heart open to the benign indifference of the universe.
To feel it so like myself, indeed, so brotherly, made me realize that I'd been happy, and that I was happy still. For all to be accomplished, for me to feel less lonely, all that remained to hope was that on the day of my execution there should be a huge crowd of spectators and that they should greet me with howls of execration."
Anyway, I *also* went to college at sixteen, mostly against the wishes of my parents (when they said 'no' to me either dropping out of high school or graduating early, I scheduled recurring meetings with my high school academic counsellor then called college admissions counsellors for schools I was interested in, and 'surprised' my parents with a high school counselor session where she repeated to them the plan I'd already set in motion -- they finally let it go through), went to a regular four-year college where the entire incoming class was older than me, then graduated with my B.S. at nineteen.
Unlike the other people you mentioned going to a regular college early, this was an excellent experience for me. I would not trade a single moment of it for any other possible college experience.
Now I'm in the mid-twenties stage of realizing I have no idea how one goes about actually contributing to the world in any way that matters, but the social experience of college definitely alleviated the ways that high-school-me thought some kinds of deep, intractable suffering were just inevitable constants in life.
Anyway, I'm not sure what the takeaway here is or whether this comment provides any particular value to your very thoughtful original post, but I just wanted to note that it was a delight to read as someone with a couple of surface-level similarities.
There seems to be a confusion somewhere in the "Telephone" chain between your psychologist, your father, your childhood self, and your adult self regarding the concept of "Performance IQ". The Performance IQ is a subscale of the Wechsler Intelligence Scales that relates to visuospatial cognition, as opposed to the Verbal IQ subscale. It has nothing to do with any "capability" vs "regular functioning" distinction. Having a Verbal > Performance (V > P) gap just means you're hyperverbal, at least in terms of your cognitive capabilities. (In contrast, a large P > V gap is characteristic of autism/Asperger's spectrum disorders.)
That said, there is a link between having a V > P gap and depression, but it's tenuous. There was some contemporary (1992) evidence that depressed people tend to have [lower performance IQs](https://sci-hub.hlgczx.com/10.1080/01688639208402828) compared to their verbal IQs and to the general population which your psychologist might have been referring to, but this seems to be a trait rather than a state: the performance–verbal gap does not appear to change post-treatment, when the patients are no longer depressed. However, most recent research shows depression-related deficits specifically in verbal fluency, not in visuospatial ability, so I tend to think of this V > P gap thing as probably just being a spurious research result (or the result of p-hacking or publication bias) and not a reflection of anything real about human cognition.
Very interesting, thank you! It’s been so long that I don’t know how I’d figure out precisely where the “telephone gap” occurred, but this information is still very interesting.
My spatial reasoning is notably inferior to my verbal skills at the best of times.
edit: I updated the post to reflect this new info and left a footnote! Thank you again for the correction.
I'm also a former gifted kid that had problems with school. I did have IQ tests as a child, but I have no idea what my actual number is other than that it was very high. I could tell my story in varying levels of detail but I've been telling it a lot recently for various reasons and I don't have the time to write it out again at the moment. Maybe later, if someone wants to read it.
Oddly enough, one way my "school was awful" story was different from a lot of other people's was that I was actually reasonably popular in high school. It was the dot-com boom of the late 1990s, and people saw a smart computer geek and thought "future tech billionaire" instead of "victim". My social life in college went downhill after my sophomore year, though. :/
if you would like some credentials, i’ve been on Jasons end of a few of my friends spiritual awakenings. this was unintentional at first, but I’ve gotten to the point of joking about running an AaaS company (Awareness as a service lol). a lot of it come down to awareness building exercises. every time u pass thru a doorway make note of the ceiling or sky. every time u tell a story, when you list the friends who participated at the start, the order reflects your own opinions of them melded with the perceived social standing they have. youre welcome for that cognitohazard lol. you are now manually breathing. just paying attention to everything all the time instead of checking out (as R.A.W. would call Rational Robots; Prometheus Rising is a decent explanation I came across recently, especially of the higher level stuff) I also just introduced Integral Theory/ Law of One to them, but honestly I prefer R.A.W.’s upper 4 levels as descriptions, as opposed to second and third tier from integral theory. I can tell by ur writing that ur high in conscientiousness. Im glad u have experimented a lot with psychoactive compounds, but I noticed you talked about doing them in controlled, safe environments. Most anxiety/depression is two sides of same coin. I’d recommend only doing drugs whimsically and spontaneously and trying to break out of the Mind as manager of the body
Thanks for the comment. I don't advocate for the perspective you're describing here, and I especially don't advocate for only doing drugs whimsically and spontaneously. But I appreciate that you took the time to share your thoughts.
my one other message is to keep the faith, even in the greatest darkness. everything we encounter is a Word of God… and so in some way holy… the strife in the world comes about when we are unable to fully grasp how sacred all of Creation is… thus we blaspheme, or Sin (any long term inefficient action from a non-dual perspective). The biggest substacker I’ve found who addresses this directly is below (see his work on Teleological Objects)
from the description of your childhood and your spiritual understanding of awareness, I have some friends for you. I’ve spent the past few years deep diving into the nature of reality, and finding others who do too. (belief is almost everything, I call the physical the “yardstick” of belief) were all the same person lmao. the similarities are ridiculous. anyway, i like to go around collecting people who get it (adding them to my friend collection). also, if you want to have “Jason-like” experiences, we channel all the time. its advanced in here, but i have no doubts about ur ability to fit right it. message evan or zoysia on the server and tell them eliott sent u. cheers. https://discord.gg/uWG4tv3KP
Thank you for sharing. I think being a stay at home mom is way more important than it may look to some, and having smart women in that role is not a bad thing, it’s good (assuming that’s what they want to be doing of course).
Having a same-age, equally gifted cohort is so important. I was in an excellent gifted program through 8th grade. I was the best student in my class, but only had a couple of friends. For high school, I went off to a public boarding school for math + science nerds. I was no longer the top student -- far from it -- but I finally had a normal social life. My roommates and I stayed up all night playing video games and listening to illegally downloaded mp3s. I dated a boy who I met on the math team.
It's sad how California has turned away from gifted education. My husband grew up in California and didn't have any friends until he started in a GATE program in 4th grade. He's still good friends with his GATE classmates. Today, GATE doesn't really exist. Even if a district has a process for identifying gifted kids, they aren't pulled out into a separate class or program. They don't get to meet their peers until high school or maybe even college.
I understand that the public schools need to focus on the kids at the other end of the spectrum, but it gives me little motivation to enroll my own son in a public school.
I went to Yale when I was 16, which was a regrettable decision, but I'll save the story for another comment.
That's powerful stuff. I also had a rough time in school and with my mental health. I also took comfort in Zen Speaks, Laozi Speaks, Confucius Speaks, growing up. The Chinese language ones came out in 1987 and 1988, when I was 6 or 7 years old, my godparents gave them to me.
My first involuntary admit was at age 6 for an autistic meltdown (in the 1980s) and I was brought in by the police. My parents were pissed. I grew up in District 75 - segregated special ed, and considered too dangerous to be around normal kids.
Because of this, I was harangued by my parents for being in a punitive, segregated public school in the first place, compared to gifted kids who attended Bronx Science, and for my hospitalizations bankrupting them. So and so's kid goes to Brooklyn Tech, and you don't even have a chance to prove yourself due to a forced IEP.
What a forced IEP meant was, even if I passed the Brooklyn Tech exam, I was barred due to my court appointed, "needs".
For my weekends, I wanted Chinese school and academic cram school and violin, not autism therapies. I came from a perfect, hard working immigrant family, my mom worked 60 hours a week, with so many resources that my brother was gifted. But I knew we were more privileged than most other families.
I felt even smaller when I realized, that gifted kids parents were poorer than mine. That their families of five lived in studio apartments, while we had 1 bedroom. Meanwhile I got the cops called on me at school because I didn't know I was being aggressive in my tone of voice. They call it a lack of insight in psychology.
I felt ashamed of being special needs. But now that I read the experiences of gifted kids I realize I maybe didn't get the short end of the stick after all. Gifted school is a form of special ed, too.
I eventually got along, we played connect 4, Jenga, and Uno. My school mates escape was Hip Hop, Anime, and arcade games similar to D&D, such as Street Fighter. This wasn't permitted under afterschool rules, and a bunch of us got teacher and state enforced parental punishments *at home* because we watched Akira. Nevertheless, I internalized the feelings of inferiority. As we got older, antipsychotics made most people gain weight. I didn't see people doing well. It sucked. I wanted to do well and to escape the special ed scene.
Now in my 40s, I notice that nobody in my school got married or had kids. I'm glad that you were able to have a kid and escape the cycle. I am 44 years old and as a female growing up in special schools I don't want my kid to go through the demoralization and 2 hour short bus rides. But at the same time gifted school isn't the answer either.
School is supposed to teach you reading, writing and arithmetic and to connect you to the kids around you in your neighborhood. My brother went to a gifted high school in Brooklyn. This also gave him problems because he had less diverse life experiences. As you can see yourself, the high pressure in gifted schools can make you suicidal until you start reading the Bible. The solution, IMO is to just have zoned schools. I think we should be connecting to our neighbors. The one room school house? Yes please.
I'm so sorry to hear about your struggles and your shame. Thank you so much for sharing about your experience.
Well my point is, it sounds like gifted labeling is just as bad as special ed. Especially due to the high expectations. It really sucks to be separated from your peers at a young age. For me, it happened earlier, and for you, it happened later, but no matter. It's still rough.
Thanks for sharing, I’ve had my own struggles with depression and suicidal ideation in my youth but would have trouble sharing any of it. I’m glad you can get out there and be true to yourself now. I’ve always been curious about spiritual experiences. I have always been a complete atheist who has never experienced anything remotely like that despite experimenting with psychedelics to see if I could have those kinds of experiences. Hallucinations and bad trips are not what I consider spiritual experiences. Then again I’m someone who doesn’t even respond well to mdma.
Thanks! I’m trying to share more about spiritual experience but it’s definitely tricky because the range of experience is so widespread, and people are very sensitive about it. What sort of curiosity do you have?
(And sorry that this comment took so long! This post got a lot of comments right away, and I got overwhelmed, so now I am coming back to it, but it’s been a few months in the meantime.)
Oddly relatable. I had similar ennui and was also institutionalized and medicated against my will in my youth, for weeks. I'm determined to ensure my children do not have similar, negative experiences and have come to similar conclusions as your cohort theory.
Thank you for sharing - I’m so sorry to hear that you had a similar experience. Please keep in touch about how your thoughts evolve in terms of handling this for children ❤️
(Side note, sorry that this comment took so long! This post got a lot of comments right away, and I got overwhelmed, so now I am coming back to it, but it’s been a few months in the meantime.)
Pet ferrets? I ❤️ ferrets! They're so playful and really cute, and I loved to watch them run around and explore. It's a lot like having kittens, which makes sense because both ferrets and cats fill basically the same evolutionary niche, being obligate carnivores that hunt mice and other small rodents. Mine liked to lick my forehead...
They are actually the best! 💙
I can relate to much though far from all of this, and I have Thoughts (tm). I went to college at sixteen also-- but a "regular" college, after having gone to a very college-like New England preppy boarding school at twelve, and having taken AP classes in middle school. Do you remember the old show "Head of the Class" with Janice the 11 year old in AP history? I still cringe at the similarities sometimes. And now I have a nerdy 13 year old son, on a much more outwardly conventional trajectory, but with his own quirks and strengths that I love and find deeply fulfilling to engage with.
So, some thoughts:
-- I don't know where you grew up, but I grew up in rural upstate NY in the eighties, and am delighted that the Bay Area in 2025 is a totally different, infinitely easier place to be a nerdy kid. You just don't need to work much to find similarly-intellectual community. Also, there is no need to skip grades to get full intellectual stimulation, which is great, because while skipping grades was the right solution for my time and place, the resultant age difference had some BIG downsides. You can imagine the social challenges of being a twelve-year-old ninth grade boy who is well under five feet tall and still has a soprano voice!
-- I also had excellent parents, who did a lot of aristocratic tutoring themselves despite their busyness, and hired tutors when they didn't have the time or subject matter expertise. Erik Hoel's posts about the effectiveness of aristocratic tutoring are spot on. But I hadn't appreciated, until my son got to reading age, how much easier it's gotten in our generation. Obviously a Kindle replaces many trips to the bookstore. Beast Academy and Art of Problem Solving are the best math teachers I know. But the most underrated trick I've found is strategic use of podcasts. Got chores, or hikes, or any other time-consuming activity your kid otherwise would get bored with? Put in the earbuds and put on a podcast. We started with Greeking Out and NPR's But Why and are now most of the way through the Mike Duncan oeuvre: History of Rome, Revolutions, and the fan-nonfic spinoffs like History of Byzantium.
-- Be careful with how you handle the Big Bang Theory. Sheldon Cooper is such an attractive character for "that type of kid" for obvious reasons... and such a terrible, terrible role model. I eventually had successful frank talks with my son about his flaws, but it took a few tries.
-- The other tricky problem I've found is how to handle conscientiousness-building. High intelligence so often comes with low, or relatively low, conscientiousness that ultimately limits agency. It certainly did for me: I could have been a much more successful research mathematician if I hadn't spent so much time playing Civ III in grad school, could have been a much more accomplished musician if I'd had any practice discipline at all before the age of 25, etc etc. I try and focus as much of my tutoring effort as I can around this, but it's always hard, emotionally and practically.
Thank you for commenting! I grew up in Hastings-on-Hudson, New York. It's a village in Westchester County, which is a bit north of New York City, on the Metro-North line. It is a really nice place, and overall I'm glad that I grew up there, but I haven't gone back in a long time.
I've had that thought about podcasts, but I have been remiss so far in exposing my son. I will redouble my efforts!
I walked through Hastings on Hudson the other day on a wooded trail passing between the Bronx, and the Croton reservoir. The crosswalk light was broken, and I got a bottle of water at Stop and Shop.
The route is called the Croton Aqueduct Trail and it traces the original path of water from the reservoir in Croton on Hudson, into the city. I start the route just south of Bronx Community College.
I remember the Aqueduct! It really is such a beautiful place. I made a drawing I liked of the Palisades when I was a teenager but I'm not sure if I still have a copy anywhere... maybe I'll see if my mother has one.
Nice. That’s awesome. I also enjoy walking around the Palisades, which are accessible by foot from the Washington Heights bridge. The Shore Trail is nice, but requires hard boots due to the sharp rocks. I consider you to be an honorary Native NYCer because Hastings is right over the border from the Bronx and basically the same as Yonkers.
I had gotten sidetracked last week, Lydia, but just finished this - thank you for sharing. I had not known about Simon's Rock but wish I had attended in another life. I was the only kindergartener in the GT program, skipped first grade, but my formal education was more or less a downhill disaster from there on out. I am still struggling to finish educating myself in both timeless and immediately useful ways while learning to make money, balance motherhood, etc. Hoping my kids can avoid some of this ... tumult.
I do go back and forth about the necessity of same age peers. Certainly there were times when I felt even 1-1.5 years of age gap clearly separated me from my classmates, post grade skip. But it was impossible to know how much of that was a factor of the lockstepedness of the grade system, or how I might have felt back with my age peers (possibly even worse). But many proposals for academic acceleration would result in more and bigger age gaps, though not enough to totally destabilize existing age-grade levels. Hard to say whether appropriate academics are or are not more important than staying with same age peers, and it's a false dichotomy anyways because enough bright kids exist to group them if we really want to.
Happily, this problem is completely avoided for us for now because GT School (like Alpha) uses moderately mixed age classrooms, 2-3 years, and advancement is dependent on meeting certain objectives so you can move up staggered throughout the year. This allows teachers to work on life skills that are appropriate for that age group but the apps will let those students work as far ahead at core academics as ends up being appropriate.
This all makes sense, Pamela! Thanks for sharing the info about GT School. I'm very curious about these up-and-coming tech-enabled education programs, all of which were unimaginable when I was a kid.
FWIW, our kid's Montessori school doesn't use any tech but similarly has mixed-age classrooms and lets kids move up at their own pace. I feel confident that he's being appropriately challenged, even if the program isn't targeted at gifted kids per se.
Good post, asking the right questions at times in your own way. I’ve come around to several of those questions too, partially because I graduated high school at 15 and was always acknowledged as gifted by parents who tried to lift me to full potential without understanding what that meant. But my story was different from yours socially and I realized quickly I didn’t want to be alone. Ironically, I’m now quite a solitary person despite looking normal and having had a career in - of all places -the military. But my course took me into an obsession with the development and shape of institutions and status, which is a topic some of those distasteful people are bringing up more openly. We need to talk about it, maybe not openly but with each other, having the experiences we have had.
What to do with intellect? What’s it for?
It’s very unpopular to say this, but I think you have to give the institutions a lot of leeway and the benefit of the doubt.
We don’t like this, because we’re a society filled with iconoclasm and fever dreams of personal freedom, all about authenticity and self expression.
But we’re also a bourgeois society, promoting equality and a comfortable, amiable conformity underneath the dressings of a liberated culture. The individualism is a reaction to that bourgeois conformity.
But that conformity is a reaction again, to societies that spent centuries and centuries built around aristocracy and a belief that some people were, both figuratively and measurably, better than others.
That’s so distasteful now, but we’re not over it. The child genius phenomenon was huge from the 70s to about 9/11, and no one asked why genius was importantly because it was so obvious. The geniuses would develop the technology, re-engineer the social norms and the culture. They had to be on top of the technocracy, as they were the only ones who understood it. It was taken for granted that status would be desirable but so would a desire to be normal, which is a paradox but one we were supposed to think of way out of, like concern for status was beneath real genius. It’s true and it’s not, and a lot of that goes back to our religious moral foundations.
There’s no easy answer, but more alarming for those with the intellect to spiral into these things, there’s no hard answer either. We run to communities that get us, but they aren’t better, just less lonely. We aren’t really better than those with a middling standard deviation, we can just do more, and we will never process all the conflicting variables that want to be accepted and trusted while also wanting to be the exception with greater relevance than the normal ones.
Life is messy. That’s all I’ve got, and I no longer believe there’s some light at the end of the tunnel where we can settle on anything other than just being whatever mask we make. I think I’m okay with that. It doesn’t hurt, it’s just the same discomfort every living thing goes through adapting to an environment that wasn’t built for us.
We aren’t owed an environment that’s built for us. That’s the fact for everyone, and those of us who respect our minds might rebel against it, but it’s an empty rebellion. We can build our spaces, but we will change within them. Maybe we want to find our true love in the entire universe, but we have to settle with being friends. It’s okay. We can take it.
Can you say more about how you think it would help to give institutions more leeway and benefit of the doubt on this subject? I have to say, I’ve just become more and more distrustful of them over time.
Everyone has. You’re not alone.
But we also need institutions. They are the context of our lives. Animals live in a natural environment, we live in a social environment, so while everyone wants to be a free thinker and unaffected, very few of us are in any significant way. The individual is a social construction.
So being interested in the institutions is necessary to understanding people. You can get political, changing what you don’t like, but it’s very difficult to pull off and there are deeper problems with the system and I don’t want to tell you what to believe. The most specific I want to get is just to remind you that you can, as it is, build your own new institutions right now. Being able to do that is the best aspect of where we are, and we aren’t doing it enough.
I’m not telling you to blindly follow. But I will tell you that rebellion for its own sake is keeping things from working well now.
When everyone dislikes the institutions, the people who try to get into them and gain position are going to be people with either little awareness or little interest in what their society thinks. In other words, dumb or trashy. Why would a good person who’s respected join an institution that’s widely seen as beneath respect?
That’s where we are. I know our culture worked better at one time, and I believe one of the reasons was because they interacted with authority in good faith, the critical aspect was moderated by some kind of ingrained respect.
I see. Totally agreed, and that’s basically where I landed on this question several years ago, too. I don’t see how we get out of this mess without building new institutions. OTOH, that’s exactly what Simon’s Rock tried to do, so one of the underlying themes in my essay here is the question of whether it could be considered a success or a failure
This is fascinating to me, because I had a sort-of similar experience that differs in all the most meaningful ways.
I don't know that I'm particularly intelligent (I've never taken an IQ test and it seems extraordinarily unlikely that I'd end up in the 150s), but I at least got good grades without any effort and won state math competitions, so I have to be a bit above average, I think. I was never bullied or ostracized for it though -- my family moved every one to two years growing up, so I think I was never part of the "background noise" enough to really be persistently targeted in any meaningful way. I didn't have any friendships that really mattered as a kid, but neither was I made fun of.
Around age 12 or 13, I lost my childhood faith (went from Catholic to atheist) and started thinking a lot about suicide. I never had a meaningful plan or anything and I never told anyone, so luckily this didn't cause me any particular problems (to this day, I've never talked to a therapist, and I seem to be getting along okay).
My own book that I got deeply obsessed with (circa age 14) to make sense of everything was The Stranger by Albert Camus, which I fell deeply in love with and reread endlessly, especially the ending right before the main character is executed:
"It was as if that great rush of anger had washed me clean, emptied me of hope, and, gazing up at the dark sky spangled with its signs and stars, for the first time, the first, I laid my heart open to the benign indifference of the universe.
To feel it so like myself, indeed, so brotherly, made me realize that I'd been happy, and that I was happy still. For all to be accomplished, for me to feel less lonely, all that remained to hope was that on the day of my execution there should be a huge crowd of spectators and that they should greet me with howls of execration."
Anyway, I *also* went to college at sixteen, mostly against the wishes of my parents (when they said 'no' to me either dropping out of high school or graduating early, I scheduled recurring meetings with my high school academic counsellor then called college admissions counsellors for schools I was interested in, and 'surprised' my parents with a high school counselor session where she repeated to them the plan I'd already set in motion -- they finally let it go through), went to a regular four-year college where the entire incoming class was older than me, then graduated with my B.S. at nineteen.
Unlike the other people you mentioned going to a regular college early, this was an excellent experience for me. I would not trade a single moment of it for any other possible college experience.
Now I'm in the mid-twenties stage of realizing I have no idea how one goes about actually contributing to the world in any way that matters, but the social experience of college definitely alleviated the ways that high-school-me thought some kinds of deep, intractable suffering were just inevitable constants in life.
Anyway, I'm not sure what the takeaway here is or whether this comment provides any particular value to your very thoughtful original post, but I just wanted to note that it was a delight to read as someone with a couple of surface-level similarities.
Thank you for sharing!!
There seems to be a confusion somewhere in the "Telephone" chain between your psychologist, your father, your childhood self, and your adult self regarding the concept of "Performance IQ". The Performance IQ is a subscale of the Wechsler Intelligence Scales that relates to visuospatial cognition, as opposed to the Verbal IQ subscale. It has nothing to do with any "capability" vs "regular functioning" distinction. Having a Verbal > Performance (V > P) gap just means you're hyperverbal, at least in terms of your cognitive capabilities. (In contrast, a large P > V gap is characteristic of autism/Asperger's spectrum disorders.)
That said, there is a link between having a V > P gap and depression, but it's tenuous. There was some contemporary (1992) evidence that depressed people tend to have [lower performance IQs](https://sci-hub.hlgczx.com/10.1080/01688639208402828) compared to their verbal IQs and to the general population which your psychologist might have been referring to, but this seems to be a trait rather than a state: the performance–verbal gap does not appear to change post-treatment, when the patients are no longer depressed. However, most recent research shows depression-related deficits specifically in verbal fluency, not in visuospatial ability, so I tend to think of this V > P gap thing as probably just being a spurious research result (or the result of p-hacking or publication bias) and not a reflection of anything real about human cognition.
Very interesting, thank you! It’s been so long that I don’t know how I’d figure out precisely where the “telephone gap” occurred, but this information is still very interesting.
My spatial reasoning is notably inferior to my verbal skills at the best of times.
edit: I updated the post to reflect this new info and left a footnote! Thank you again for the correction.
I'm also a former gifted kid that had problems with school. I did have IQ tests as a child, but I have no idea what my actual number is other than that it was very high. I could tell my story in varying levels of detail but I've been telling it a lot recently for various reasons and I don't have the time to write it out again at the moment. Maybe later, if someone wants to read it.
Oddly enough, one way my "school was awful" story was different from a lot of other people's was that I was actually reasonably popular in high school. It was the dot-com boom of the late 1990s, and people saw a smart computer geek and thought "future tech billionaire" instead of "victim". My social life in college went downhill after my sophomore year, though. :/
if you would like some credentials, i’ve been on Jasons end of a few of my friends spiritual awakenings. this was unintentional at first, but I’ve gotten to the point of joking about running an AaaS company (Awareness as a service lol). a lot of it come down to awareness building exercises. every time u pass thru a doorway make note of the ceiling or sky. every time u tell a story, when you list the friends who participated at the start, the order reflects your own opinions of them melded with the perceived social standing they have. youre welcome for that cognitohazard lol. you are now manually breathing. just paying attention to everything all the time instead of checking out (as R.A.W. would call Rational Robots; Prometheus Rising is a decent explanation I came across recently, especially of the higher level stuff) I also just introduced Integral Theory/ Law of One to them, but honestly I prefer R.A.W.’s upper 4 levels as descriptions, as opposed to second and third tier from integral theory. I can tell by ur writing that ur high in conscientiousness. Im glad u have experimented a lot with psychoactive compounds, but I noticed you talked about doing them in controlled, safe environments. Most anxiety/depression is two sides of same coin. I’d recommend only doing drugs whimsically and spontaneously and trying to break out of the Mind as manager of the body
Thanks for the comment. I don't advocate for the perspective you're describing here, and I especially don't advocate for only doing drugs whimsically and spontaneously. But I appreciate that you took the time to share your thoughts.
my one other message is to keep the faith, even in the greatest darkness. everything we encounter is a Word of God… and so in some way holy… the strife in the world comes about when we are unable to fully grasp how sacred all of Creation is… thus we blaspheme, or Sin (any long term inefficient action from a non-dual perspective). The biggest substacker I’ve found who addresses this directly is below (see his work on Teleological Objects)
https://substack.com/@eridanus?r=60i6fd&utm_medium=ios&utm_source=profile&shareImageVariant=light
from the description of your childhood and your spiritual understanding of awareness, I have some friends for you. I’ve spent the past few years deep diving into the nature of reality, and finding others who do too. (belief is almost everything, I call the physical the “yardstick” of belief) were all the same person lmao. the similarities are ridiculous. anyway, i like to go around collecting people who get it (adding them to my friend collection). also, if you want to have “Jason-like” experiences, we channel all the time. its advanced in here, but i have no doubts about ur ability to fit right it. message evan or zoysia on the server and tell them eliott sent u. cheers. https://discord.gg/uWG4tv3KP
Thank you for sharing. I think being a stay at home mom is way more important than it may look to some, and having smart women in that role is not a bad thing, it’s good (assuming that’s what they want to be doing of course).