Last week, a writer contacted me to ask how I feel about a certain quote that was attributed to me in The New Yorker last year. The writer in question is an indie, unaffiliated with any specific publication. She contacted me because she was planning to cite the quote, but then she remembered that I expressed mixed feelings about the article. So she didn’t want to surface the quote in a new piece without asking me.
I really appreciate that she did this. Her inquiry reminded me that some humans actually manage to care about other humans who end up in the public spotlight, which is something I have been feeling demoralized about.
So it meant a lot to me that this writer put forth the human effort of asking me, before choosing to surface the quote in a new context. No one, including me, would have blamed her for quoting the New Yorker quote, which is in the public record. But she checked with me before doing it, even though she didn’t have to go to the trouble. It felt like a breath of fresh air.
Aside from making me feel better about humanity, her inquiry motivated me to go back through some files I’ve been meaning to review.
—
Let’s go back to last year, when the New Yorker article was published. The article was about my ex-fiancé, Curtis Yarvin. After the article was published, I wrote a short statement. I said some important things in that statement. Also, there were many things I did not say in that statement.
One thing I did not say was that I felt confused about this quote. Here’s the quote:
[Lydia Laurenson] told me that the ethos of her relationship with Yarvin was “ ‘We’re going to be geniuses together and have genius babies.’ I’m making fun of it a little bit, but that really was it.”
This quote has now been broadcast to many thousands — maybe millions — of people. Many people attacked me on social media specifically due to that quote. (Often, they didn’t read the article and only saw the quote in a screenshot, because screenshots of viral articles get shared around on Twitter-like platforms.)
When the article came out, I did not remember saying this, and I suspected there was missing context. Also, at the time, I had some other concerns about the fact-checking process on the article, plus I was upset about how the reporter handled sourcing. I contacted the reporter and the fact-checker and I tried to give feedback. Neither seemed interested in feedback. I waited to see if they would take time to think about it and circle back. They didn’t.
I found this entire process depressing. But I didn’t have much energy to do anything about it. Anyway, what was I going to do? — send a letter to the editor, which I assumed they would ignore, the same way the fact-checker and the reporter ignored my feedback? Plus, at the time I was working hard on a journalistic article for a separate outlet, so I had professional reasons to not make a fuss with the New Yorker; no one wants to needlessly upset heavyweights in their field.
I wrote my statement at the time to make several specific points, largely about framing rather than process, and I weathered the social media backlash, and I went and did other things.
For the last year, I’ve left the whole thing alone. However, I have a recording of my session with the reporter, because I took my own recording during the interview process. (Interestingly, the reporter called me after our interview and said that me taking my own recording was highly unusual, and then the reporter tried to convince me to delete my recording of our session. Obviously, I did not delete it.) A few days ago, I finally had the spare time and energy to retrieve the recording and check the quote.
As it turns out, I did say those words… sort of. The quote was part of a broader discussion about the psychology of “gifted kids.” Here’s the quote, alongside a paragraph of other stuff I said:
I think one of the things that is notable about this community is: A lot of us have tested very high on IQ tests. That can kind of run away with you, if you let it. You can get in this sort of, like, weird psychological cul-de-sac about how you’re a “gifted kid” and you should have more capacity, or power, or whatever — like people “should” respect you more, right? I think Curtis really taps into that. One of the things that [Curtis and I] bonded over was that we both did the Center for Talented Youth “Gifted and Talented” program. And he went to college when he was 15. I went when I was 16. It was like, we’re gonna be geniuses together and have genius babies, right? I’m making fun of it a little bit, but that really was… (slight pause, shift gears to discussing something else)
So… okay.
Now that I have reviewed the context, I remember the conversation better. Here is what I was trying to say:
• The tech community, and the neoreactionary right-wing community (which overlaps with the tech community but is separate), contains many individuals who scored highly on IQ tests as children.
• Getting very high scores on IQ tests is an unusual experience. This experience typically has a major psychological impact, which is both good and bad. (Last year, I wrote a piece about my experience going to college at age sixteen that discusses this issue further.)
• When we met, my ex-fiancé and I quickly realized that we share a number of unusual childhood experiences, including: Receiving high scores on childhood IQ tests; being selected into a “Gifted and Talented” program called the Center for Talented Youth; and going to college early. Curtis and I bonded over this. This was a complex psychological interaction between me and him, which was mostly about shared experience, but additionally it was not lost on me that IQ is a heritable genetic trait. (Sidenote: There’s a PUA analysis to be done here, about how it’s hard for men to DHV me who can’t compete on this trait; this has created funny psychological problems for me in the past, and probably still does!)
I am aware that many critiques can be made about IQ, and about types of intelligence, et cetera. I do not have a take on those critiques. All I am trying to say is that the experience of being identified and trained from childhood in this manner can profoundly shape a person. This is especially true for those of us who don’t feel like we find space for ourselves in mainstream workplaces.
None of this is a political point — or not exactly — but it sort of is a political point? I have personally met people on the far right, far left, and in the political center who have high IQs. So I don’t think political affiliation is about IQ. However, I also think there’s a problematic elitism that can easily infect people who have been diagnosed with high IQs. This elitism has consequences for political philosophy, whether it manifests on the left or the right.
I have spent a lot of effort guarding against this elitism in myself; in fact, the main reason I was attracted to the neoreactionary movement in the first place was that they had a critique of elitism I found very trenchant. (Last year, I wrote more about my experience in the neoreactionary movement in this piece.) Unfortunately, I now believe the neoreactionary elitist critique to be a smokescreen; but it’s an impressive smokescreen, which makes numerous good points on their own merits.
So, to be clear, here is the point I was trying to make: Getting high scores on IQ tests, and getting sorted into programs that are intended to help high-IQ people, is an experience with specific psychological effects; and in the communities Curtis and I share, there are many people who had this experience; and he and I connected over this experience on a personal level. All of this is true regardless of whether IQ measures a real thing, and regardless of whether the tests are accurate. I’m talking about a psychological crucible here, I’m not making some elitist moral claim.
—
It’s probably tasteless of me to be so direct about this. It feels uncomfortable. When I wrote my piece last year about the experience of going to college at age sixteen, I was nervous to publish it, because I didn’t like the sense of “outing” myself. That piece contains a lot of vulnerable personal experience, not only about getting high IQ tests but also about other aspects of being so-called “neurodivergent,” which often goes along with high IQ. I was so anxious when I posted it last year that I wanted to throw up. Sometimes I still feel nauseated when I think about discussing this subject publicly.
But, in recent years I’ve started to understand more and more, firstly, how strong an impact these programs and diagnoses had on my life, and secondly, that I am not alone. And, as anyone who is familiar with my prior writing can attest, I am unlikely to let stigma stop me from articulating a shared experience, at least not after I figure out that it’s a shared experience.
I believe there is a lot of value currently left on the table, when it comes to helping people who are IQ 140+. I think identifying and trying to help this group of people, especially while young, is a worthy endeavor. If you’re a “gifted kid,” it’s pretty easy to come out of childhood feeling like you’ll never find friends, that everyone hates you, that you don’t understand your own value to society, and that you don’t know where to go or what to do with yourself.
This is bad! We should try to find more ways to ensure that our smartest citizens don’t grow up feeling this way! We should also be trying to train our high-IQ kids with a positive sense of focused virtue and good character! The phrase “special needs” is generally taken to mean low-IQ individuals, but believe me, “gifted kids” have special needs.
Community integration like this, whether for “gifted kids” or others, does not usually happen by itself. It works better when people build community spaces and institutions for it. I suspect that, given network effects and advances in communications technology, we could unlock some really cool ways for humans to work together and create new wonders, maybe build some new institutions relevant to this problem. I don’t know exactly how to deal with this problem, but I know that I care about kids who go through this, because I was one of them.
•
—
—


How much interaction have you had with Jack Despain Zhou (aka TracingWoodgrains) and his Center for Educational Progress nonprofit? Inasmuch as I can think of anyone in the present institutional/cultural mix trying to do better by and for "gifted kids" it's those folks.
I was in a documentary that was made to try to call attention to the issue over forty years ago. The institutions mostly got worse over those decades, but the options outside of the institutions got vastly better. (My school district only allowed credit by exam after you’d failed a class. The incentive structure this policy created was — unsurprisingly, knowing the people who instituted it — unanticipated until I showed up. Then they were very, very mad. And we had a normal suite of AP classes, so it’s not like the concept was totally foreign to them….)